Herodotus and thucydides ^ see essay on thucydides in the rebirth of classical political rationalism: an introduction to the thought of leo strauss - essays and lectures by leo strauss, edited by thomas l pangle chicago: university of chicago press, 1989. This essay compares the works of herodotus and thucydides, and the way in which herodotus influenced thucydides' own views on the writing of history it examines differences in their language, the importance attributed to the supernatural. Jessica dam, 2015 history extension herodotus and thucydides a comparison throughout the past centuries, the ancient greek historians herodotus and thucydides have remained the central figures of the stillcontroversial question which of the two historians' methods is the most accurate, reliable. Essay preview interpreting herodotus and thucydides through the context of an intended audience our perspectives on historical events in ancient greece are heavily reliant on the context and explanations given by chroniclers and early historians of antiquity. Thucydides' reputation as a primary historian of the ancient world derives from his one work, the history of the peloponnesian war thucydides began compiling his work at the onset of the war in 431 bc, becoming one of the earliest historians to write contemporary history, and he continued to.
Like herodotus and thucydides, he probably autographed his work for the benefit of later writers herodotus identifies the land of the lotus-eaters as a headland in the territory of the gindanes tribe in libya, and thucydides reports the standard identifications mentioned above. Herodotus and thucydides invented history, or at least the writing of it, in the western world before herodotus, the greeks had no word for history in the sense of writing a narration of past events in prose sparta essay on the society of sparta. Thucydides (or thoukydides) (c 460 bc - c 400 bc) was an ancient greek historian, author of the history of the peloponnesian war, which recounts the 5th century bc war between sparta and athens this work is widely regarded a classic and represents the first work of its kind. Thucydides never mentioned herodotus by name but is thought to have taken a swipe at him in one of his introductory statements in the peloponnesian war herodotus, on the other hand, is seen as the 'sensational historian', relying on a blend of oral accounts, gossip, myths, rumors, and synthesizing it.
Most helpful essay resource ever this preview is partially blurred sign up to view the complete essay. Exiled thucydides knew all that a speech can say about democracy, and what dictators do, the elderly rubbish they talk to an apathetic grave analysed all in his book, the enlightenment driven away, the habit-forming pain, mismanagement and grief: we must suffer them all again. This paper will contrast the historical writings and thoughts of two men who are known to be the first historians the purpose is to compare and contrast them and there ideas on the capturing of historic information. Herodotus thucydides comparison intro history vs homer what is history herodotus vs thucydides thucydides: approach to history based on evidence, unlike poets and storytellers as to the events of the war, i have not written them down as i heard them from just anybody, nor as i.
Both herodotus and thucydides were ancient greek historians who invented the writings of history herodotus and thucydides were the first people ever the writings of herodotus and thucydides at times can be seen as similar, but with different intentions thucydides also seems to be more in. Herodotus is considered the father of history because his history of the persian war was the first narrative in the form that later came out be considered more importantly, herodutus was one of the first to disregard the supernatural in his writings you get this more when you get to thucydides, but. Herodotus and thucydides - the original fathers of greek historiography - are regarded as the first two historians herodotus' and thucydides' innovative methods of conveying the experience of historical events and their interpretation have emerged in the context of traditionally vibrant ancient. Moreover, thucydides' work is long, complicated, and forbidding (even in translations that strive to make it accessible), and often rather boring — admittedly characteristics that could also be ascribed to aristotle as well but why should any such author be widely cited today. 2 herodotus thucydides 3 herodotos (ηροδοτος ): means given to the hero, derived from 'ηρως (heros) hero, warrior and δοτος(dotos) given to 4 herodotus (485- 430 bc) - a greek historian who was born in halicarnassus, caria (modern-day bodrum, turkey) and lived in the fifth century bc.
See essay on thucydides in the rebirth of classical political rationalism: an introduction to the thought of leo strauss - essays and lectures by leo strauss , edited by thomas l pangle bust of thucydides residing in the royal ontario museum , toronto herodotus and thucydides. Thucydides was an athenian historian and general his history of the peloponnesian war recounts the fifth-century bc war between sparta and athens until the year 411 bc. When analyzing the writings of herodotus and thucydides, the authors must be compared and contrasted though it is almost impossible to know the another thing greatly noticed in the writings of herodotus is the stating of his opinions on the matter throughout the document he explained his. Herodotus thucydides herodotus thucydides herodotus thucydides herodotus the essays are generally of a high quality and reflect the richness of these two foundational texts students of herodotus, thucydides, and ancient historiography will read them with benefit and.
Include herodotus, thucydides, xenophen, aristotie, pausunas and plutarch all of which have extensive views and opinions on sparta herodotus tended to digress with irrelevant storytelling, whereas thucydides abandoned this technique, and. Herodotus (484-424 bc ) a greek historian, known as the father of history, who was the first historian to apply critical evaluation to his material, while also recording divergent opinions he made his prose style resemble the finest poetry by its persuasiveness, its charm, and its utterly delightful effect. Herodotus became the first person we know of to see the past in new and fresh ways—not as a distant recess shrouded in legend and rumor, but as something that lies close at hand as something that immediately affects the here and now and as a subject whose great personalities and patterns of. Although thucydides at no time mentions his great predecessor herodotus by name, he does correct a number of passages in herodotus's history for in addition, finley's three essays on thucydides (1967) is important for seeing the unity of the history and the fact that thucydides wrote from.