Jane eyre - a comparison between mr rochester and st john charlotte bronte's novel jane eyre accurately demonstrate the hardship faced by orphaned children and penniless young women in nineteenth century english society. This is evident within jane eyre when st john rivers offers jane marriage unlike mr rochester, st john does not aspire to discover jane's passion, but appreciates the 'second self' she has created ' ill or well, she would always be plain. I think it is evident to every one who reads jane eyre that, aided by the fact that chance renders the noble mr rochester partially blind, she, and not her husband, is really the head of the household this, i fancy, in the eyes of most women, makes for a happy home, and i am not bold enough to venture otherwise. It turns out that jane's uncle, mr john eyre, is a friend of mr mason's and was visited by him soon after mr eyre received jane's letter about her impending marriage after the marriage ceremony is broken off, mr rochester asks jane to go with him to the south of france, and live with him as husband and wife, even though they cannot be married.
Mr rochester is stern-featured, heavy-browed, craggy-faced, rude, abrupt, horny, twice jane's age, always on the edge of violence, likes to order people around, keeps his wife locked in the attic, and teases jane on at least one occasion until she cries. William hurt's rochester, whom i also like, is more aloof, controlled, enigmatic, etc jane later meets st john (pronounced sin-jin), who is the polar opposite of rochester, a fair adonis, appearance-wise, but cold as a fish (except in his love of the lord), and contrasts the two (much more so in the book. Charlotte bronte's jane eyre whether you love reading and analyzing works by famous authors, or simply enjoy classical novels of the bildungsroman genre, you must have heard of jane eyre by charlotte bronte at one point in time or another. Jane feels morally obligated to marry st john and emotionally obligated to marry rochester, but knows the right choice is to marry st john she eventually decides that even though [she] can imagine the possibility of conceiving an inevitable, strange, torturing kind of love for [st john], jane cannot openly love and be happy with him.
Jane eyre essay novel jane eyre using many characters as symbols in jane eyre, bronte supports the theme that routine actions are not always moral through the conventional personalities of mrs reed, mr brocklehurst, and st john rivers. Even though i love mr darcy and his subtle affection, i would say that jane eyre is actually the better of the two and, having been pouring over different mediums of both of them (movies, tv series, even manga), it's become glaringly apparent to me why i'm abruptly choosing that. Jane eyre comparison between rochester and john rivers jane eyre love, family, and independence as an orphan at gateshead, jane is oppressed and dependent for jane to discover herself, she must break out of these restrictive conditions and find love and independence. Jane eyre is, in comparison, very fortunate in her relationship with mrs fairfax, and of course in her romantic relationship with her employer which broke all the rules of social hierarchy images charlotte brontë's letter to w s williams (15 june 1848) reflects on the life of a governess.
Characterisation mr rochester and st john rivers mr rochester's growth is important to the unfolding of the plot but, as a secondary character, he is slightly less convincing than jane eyre. As jane develops her relationship with god, mr rochester must also reform his pride, learn to pray, and become humble brontë depicts different forms of religion: helen trusts in salvation eliza reed becomes a french catholic nun and st john preaches a gloomy calvinist faith. I learned only recently that charlotte bronte is a masterful writer she crafted the story of jane eyre, a tale following young, abused jane, through her experiences in school, then as a governess. Jane eyre jane eyre jane eyre of charlotte brontes jane eyre, develops drastically within the first few chapters of the novel her environment was a major influential factor in jane s development it would shape the person she is and will be. It is important to keep in mind that this version of 'jane eyre' was produced in 1973 and therefore the production quality is dated nonetheless, the screen play is excellent and the characterizations faithful to bronte's novel, a close version of which appears ten years later in the clark/dalton 'jane eyre.
Jane first meets mr rochester while running an errand for mrs fairfax (who jane had initially mistaken for her employer) she runs into his horse which causes him to fall and sprain his ankle when she returns she learns that the man she met was in fact the master of thornfield hall. Jane eyre by charlotte bronte essays - jane eyre by charlotte bronte jane eyre, a novel about an english woman's struggles told through the writing of charlotte brontë, has filled its audience with thoughts of hope, love, and deception for many years. Mr rochester arrived on the pages of his novel 34 years after mr darcy did, but internal evidence from jane eyre suggests it is set sometime around the turn of the 18/19th century, the era of pride and prejudice the two men are thus closer contemporaries than publication history indicates.
I still have a hard time seeing mr rochester as a psychopath when the book offers jane's other, and much creepier suitor, st john, as comparison st john not only has her do a bunch of tasks for the purposes of surreptitiously training her to be a good missionary's wife, he also commands jane to marry him after explicitly telling her he. St john rivers — a parson with two sisters at moor house, and jane's cousin much like jane, st john is a restless character, searching for a place and purpose in life. The easiest way to compare and contrast rochester and st john rivers is by examining when and under what circumstances these two gentlemen come into contact with jane it is at thornfield manor that jane first encounters mr rochester.
The following episode, as jane flees, is perhaps also problematic since it sees jane stumble accidentally across her long-lost eyre cousins, st john, mary and diana mary and diana do seem to be very thinly veiled portraits of charlotte's own sisters emily and anne, with the trio of girls shortly falling into a pattern of study with all three sitting round the table which does mirror their real-life habits. On a kinder note, brontë closes the novel with mr rochester's sight regained in one eye: the marriage is restored to equality and mr rochester and jane can be happy in their union st john rivers the evangelist who takes jane in at moor house, brother to diana and mary and, it turns out, cousin to jane. St john is a kind of mirror image of mr rochester, blanche ingram is in the same way a reflection of jane mr brocklehurst is in the same way an echo of miss temple this idea of reversal or opposites is used when bronte uses images connected with darkness and light to symbolise goodness and despair.
How does mr rochester compare to st john rivers throughout the novel, bronte associates mr rochester with fire and passion and st john rivers with ice and cold detachment bronte also presents jane's potential union with each man as profoundly different. Jane also manages to assert her own identity in the male-dominated society even though both mr rochester and st john rivers try to confine her to a subordinate position in order to control her she achieves this by rejecting both rochester and st john. A feminist is a person whose beliefs and behavior are based on feminism (belief in the social, political, and economic equality of the sexes) jane eyre is clearly a critique of assumptions about both gender and social class.